Women prefer a guy with a sense of humour
That's why guys who look like this
get all the chicks (pretend they aren't/weren't famous).
And guys who look like this
spend all their time in the basement playing Halo.
What they really mean is that if a girl has a choice between a guy who looks like this
DISCLAIMER: We consider all the dudes shown here to be cool and talented fellas, irrespective of musculo-skeletal condition and relative Prettiness Index.